America Needs to Just Cancel the School Year Already

Pretending that any real learning can go on during this time is just making life hell for parents and teachers alike

When I broke the news to my nine-year old daughter that we were going to be doing remote learning for the foreseeable future, she was horrified. “We’re going to have to do work while all this other crazy stuff is happening?” she asked incredulously. You’re telling me, kid.

It’s past time to call it: The school year is over. There is no real substitute for in-classroom learning. For kids who are in elementary grades, especially, continuing on as if they’re going to retain lessons under these circumstances is ridiculous.

Children understand what’s happening in the world around them, and expecting them to act as if we’re not in the middle of pandemic isn’t “normalizing”—it’s cruel.

I’m fortunate. My daughter’s school seems to understand that the best thing they can do is try to keep children’s brains nimble. We’re doing lots of math exercises and reading, and the school has offered suggestions for fun at-home science projects. But even that requires me to give up hours of my day when I should be working to supervise my daughter, and it means teachers have to work even harder during a time of crisis.

The best thing we can do right now is pay out teachers, janitors, school administrators, and counselors and start summer early. Sure, I’d love for my kid’s school to keep in touch with some virtual book club or the occasional Zoom meeting for fun — but much more than that is doing work simply for the sake of saying we’re doing it.

I’ve heard the argument that some parents need the structure for their children, but I have a hard time believing this isn’t causing more stress for working parents — mothers, especially, who do a disproportionate amount of childcare — than it is benefiting children.

I want my kid to be smart and educated as much as any other parent. But the notion of “falling behind” feels sort of small in comparison to everything else that is happening in the world.

We could all use a break, a way to make things easier — so let’s start here. It’s time to end the school year. It won’t be a cure-all for what kids, parents, and teachers are dealing with, I know. But right now, every little bit helps.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *